William Tillman faced a brutal choice: slavery or death.
He was steward and cook aboard the merchant schooner S.J. Waring, about 300 tons, bound for Montevideo, Uruguay with an assorted cargo. Three days out from port, July 7, 1861, and one hundred fifty miles from Sandy Hook, New Jersey, at lat. 38°, long. 69°.
Tillman's vessel was boarded by men from the rebel privateer Jeff Davis.
They declared the schooner property of the Confederate States of America. The Civil War was less than four months old.
Line engraving published in Harper's Weekly, 1861,
depicting the recapture of the schooner
S.J. Waring by William Tillman
.
The rebels ransacked the vessel and ordered Captain Smith, the ship's master, to haul down the Stars and Stripes. He was then taken to the privateer. Tillman was told that he, like the ship, was southern property and that he would be sold into bondage when the ship reached its new destination.
The confederates put a five man prize crew on Tillman's ship and turned her south, toward Charleston. Now, each day at sea beat down on Tillman like a hammer. An overwhelming sense of dread, however, was gradually replaced by iron-willed resolve. Tillman, in concert with a handful of passengers, hatched a bold plan.